Postby Riptide » November 11th, 2018, 4:57 pm
If I might weigh in for a minute and play a little devil's advocate.
I actually read the author's Ask Me Anything on Reddit and she actually seems pretty cool. She was a really big fan of the series like the rest of us and sort of just lucked into the chance to write the book, and, her choice of ending not withstanding, I actually like that they gave it to someone who understands and cares about the setting, as opposed to what happened with Deception, where it was VERY CLEAR that the author had never even heard of Mass Effect before.
I haven't read the books myself, but the premise itself actually makes sense. That most of the people sent on the Initiative are castoffs and deviants from their own worlds. The thing to remember is just because most volus are capitalists and merchants, not all of them are. Or that all Elcor are super chill guys who take their time with everything, Garrus references one that was a serial killer in the first game after all. And I actually think what we see of the quarians in the novel, at least from what I've read above, is pretty interesting.
I also found it amusing, that for as absurd as her plan is, the quarian captain's backstory and character are strikingly similar to what Jones and I cobbled together for Reckoning a long, long time ago. God that feels like a lifetime ago.
Also, screw you guys who say the Elcor aren't cool. I always loved some of the smaller races, and have always been really sad we never got more of them. I mean, you can't really say we got more of them because everyone in this novel has had their racial hat turned upside down, but I empathize with the author's liking of them. Not everyone's favorite race is the quarians, guys.
Anyway, I'm not really interested in reading this novel anytime soon. I feel kind of burned on Mass Effect like most of you do, and I have zero love for Andromeda. But I also do want to recognize progress where I see it. Bioware hired a fan, not a cookie cutter lazy sack of crap to write their novel this time, and I respect that the author's opinions, while different from mine, come from a place of passion for the series. And, hell, I'll be honest, the plot of the book at least sounds more interesting than anything we got in the actual game, so you know, kudos for that.
As for gays in Andromeda, just because they don't have sex with the opposite sex doesn't mean they can't contribute via sperm donation or artificial insemination. I mean, it's obvious the Andromeda Initiative is a bit of a joke, but don't let being burned out on Bioware's bullshit turn you into a prejudiced asshole, guys.
Devil's advocate, concluded.