Alright, I finished
Cyberpunk 2077. I got complex feelings about the game.
First off, is the game as good as
The Witcher 3? No. Nope. But that game was a once-in-a-decade masterpiece, where everything fell into place perfectly for me. Characters, story, graphics, music, gameplay. Everything.
Cyberpunk 2077 is still a very good game, nonetheless, but not as complete as
The Witcher 3. Total playtime was about 88 hours, if I deduct the aborted first playthrough. I think I'll go through the different aspects one by one, to keep this somewhat organized. Non-spoiler stuff, first.
Graphics:
I got a leg up on the vast majority of people, since I got (aside from the CPU, which is "only" an i7) the best rig you could possibly have to play the game, with an RTX 3090 and 32 GB RAM. So, the game looked fantastic for me, with breathtaking visuals all around. The raytraced lighting makes everything just the extra bit realistic to pull you into the game. I felt fully immersed for a long stretch of the time I played. There were more than a few bugs, though, which kept cropping up throughout the game. Some items not being interacteable, cars exploding for no reasons, some T-posing, dialogues not triggering and the like. More if it than in
The Witcher 3 at launch, if I remember back then correctly. So, yeah, the game definitely launched in an unfinished state in some aspects.
Gameplay:
I went with the sneaky hacker build, which makes the game quite easy, even on Hard difficulty. It also makes it pretty easy to be mostly non-lethal, which makes quite a few of the fixers more happy with you and also means you don't kill a thousand people or more during your game. I will be doing a second playthrough in a few months, where I'll go with a guns-a-blazing build, which I look forward to see the difference. Depending on what DLC comes out, I might continue my V's career, although the ending was quite definite, IMO. The customizability of your character is very high, however at higher levels I couldn't care less that I had only 7 dexterity and no points in the pistol tree, since I still began to two-shot opponents with no problem. The game unbalances itself the more capable you become. All in all, balance was better in
The Witcher 3, where you really could challenge yourself still. As for the rest, movement was good (parcour!) and it really felt fun zipping around Night City and the outskirts in my different cars and on the motorbikes, especially at night during rain.
An aspect I was never that much in love with was the first person view. It did feel very immersive in many moments, but when there was a short cutscene in the game showing your character fully animated from a third person view, I realized how much more I would have liked such a version of the game and how much I missed those moments from
The Witcher 3. Yep, I am pretty much going to mention that game every time I can.
Alright, going full into spoilers territory now, where I am not holding back anything. Proceed at your own peril. Of course I'll put it under tags.
Story and characters:
► Show Spoiler
Overall, the story was very good, at least in regards to the main story and some of the side content. My problem was, that I didn't connect to many of the characters as much as I did in
The Witcher 3. The characters I really liked were V, as the main protagonist, Johnny, Jackie, Takemura, Judy, Panam, Mitch and, for the short time you could spend with them, Misty and Mama Welles. I really did not feel very connected to the other characters at all. Not that they were all unappealing, but they simply made not that deep an impact on me. And since Jackie and Takemura both die (apparently you can save Takemura, which I don't know how that could be an option, but whatever) long before the story concludes and Judy disappears at the end of her storyline as well, that left only a few characters I really could feel a connection to. Compared to
The Witcher 3, where you have a vast range of characters you can gather to help you with the final missions of the game and which accompany you on many occasions in the game and who also felt much more natural as persons (I especially point to Yennefer, who was
introduced in
The Witcher 3 and still managed to leave a lasting impression on me to this day through her strong personality), it made the personal stuff feel not involved enough, IMO. The romances also feel a bit more shallow than in
The Witcher 3. Let's just say that Panam didn't make as good an impression as Yen did.
I really liked the voice-acting, which was fantastic throughout. Keanu Reeves did an excellent job, but so did all the other VA's. Especially Jackie's, IMO.
The little side stories (i.e. gigs) were not as fully fleshed out as Geralts side quests, however. No matter if I needed to steal something, plant a bug, kidnap some bad guy or whatever, I just zapped everyone with quick hacks and waltzed in to rob everything lying around. All very same-y. No witcher investigations, following trails and putting together clues. No finding clues then making diplomacy between warring vinyards. These small stories did mostly not leave the emotional impact much of the smaller stuff had in
The Witcher 3. I think only one gig really shook me, where I had to decide the fate of a father/son duo, which were editors for kiddy snuff BD's. I reloaded that two times, just to kill everyone as painfully as I could. And I played V as non-lethal as possible otherwise. But as for the rest? Pfffft. "Hey, V, some goomba needs to be taken out". "Okay" <zap, zap, zap> "Cool, V, here are your eddies!". Mostly it was like that, which felt quite a bit boring.
As for the ending(s), I got the, IMO, best one, where I end up with Panam and leave with the Aldecaldos, having joined a new family and left the cesspool of Night City behind us, while Johnny went off with Alt Cunningham into cyberspace. Basically, the Fast and Furious ending.

In the ending I got, the game leaves you with the cliffhanger that you still are dying slowly, but at least gives you hope that it can be avoided. Which I hope the expansions will be about. I've looked at the other endings (the secret ending included) and I must conclude that I did as good as I could.
All in all, I come away happy from the experience, but also a bit drained. It wasn't as good an experience as
The Witcher 3 was, but that at least still makes that game the best game of my life. Wheeee!

Now that CD Projekt Red has to recover some goodwill with gamers overall, I'm pretty sure that, after they finished all the content they want to bring out for
Cyberpunk 2077, they'll return to the Witcherverse and give us a new story there. Looking forward to that!
Now, I got eight more days of free time, much more than I anticipated. I guess it's more
WoW: Shadowlands for me, together with maybe some
Crusader Kings 3 and lots of other, non-computer-gamey stuff as well.